The Three Leadership Blind Spots That Undermine High-Performing Teams

leadership psychological safety team building Mar 01, 2025
Leader not working well with his team

Even the most talented leaders can fall prey to blind spots that quietly erode team performance. Drawing from three decades of experience in the employment space and my People-Forward Leadership™ framework, I've identified three critical blind spots that consistently undermine otherwise high-performing teams.

Understanding how these blind spots interact with the framework's three pillars—Leader Awareness, Empowered Ecosystem, and Collective Learning—provides a powerful lens for transforming leadership challenges into opportunities for growth.

Blind Spot #1: Failing to Go From Expert to Catalyst

Many leaders struggle to transition from being the subject matter expert to becoming a catalyst for growth and development. This fundamental shift in self-perception requires deep Leader Awareness and challenges how leaders define their own value and success.

Signs this blind spot is affecting your team:

  • You define your value by your technical expertise rather than your ability to develop others.
  • Your calendar lacks dedicated time for coaching and mentoring activities.
  • You feel a need to demonstrate your expertise in every meeting or discussion.
  • You experience frustration when work isn't done "your way."
  • You struggle with insecurity or control issues when not actively solving problems yourself.

The solution: Use Leader Awareness to transform your leadership identity

Harvard Business Review research indicates that leaders who are directly involved in developing their team members and who deliberately allocate time for these activities see a marked improvement in team performance. Specifically, teams led by development-focused managers perform better in productivity metrics by up to 25%.

Through the Leader Awareness pillar of People-Forward Leadership™:

  1. Reframe your internal narrative about your value as a leader – from "I am valuable because I know the answers" to "I am valuable because I develop others."
  2. Recognize that great leaders are master conductors, orchestrating talent rather than performing every instrument.
  3. Develop the self-awareness to identify when your ego is driving a need to showcase expertise.
  4. Transform your leadership mindset from hierarchical expertise to developmental partnership.
  5. Schedule regular reflection time to honestly assess your comfort level with being a catalyst rather than an expert.

A marketing executive I coached struggled with this identity transition after being promoted from the company's star to CMO. Through our work on Leader Awareness, she confronted her deep-seated belief that her technical expertise was her primary value to the organization. She realized she was defining success by how many technical problems she solved rather than by how she developed others.

By fundamentally reframing her leadership identity from "technical expert" to "talent developer," she transformed her approach and sense of purpose. Within a few months of seeing the value in elevating her team for her own growth and success, her team was highly proactive and functioning almost independently, finally giving her the bandwidth to focus on strategic initiatives. As she put it, "I used to think my job was to be the smartest person in the room. Now I know my job is to create a room full of people smarter than me."

Blind Spot #2: Underestimating the Power of Psychological Safety

Many leaders intellectually understand the importance of psychological safety but fail to recognize when it's lacking in their own teams. This blind spot directly undermines the Collective Learning pillar of effective leadership.

Signs this blind spot is affecting your team:

  • Innovation is met with resistance.
  • The same voices dominate discussions while others remain silent.
  • Mistakes are hidden rather than used as learning opportunities.
  • Feedback flows primarily top-down rather than in all directions.
  • Communication is triangulated.

The solution: Use psychological safety to foster Collective Learning 

Atlassian reports that the benefits of psychological safety at work include a 27% reduction in turnover, 76% more engagement, and 50% more productivity. When employees feel psychologically safe, their performance can be up to 5x higher, which in turn leads to greater innovation.

Creating an environment for Collective Learning requires the following:

  1. Leading with vulnerability by sharing when you don't know something and admitting mistakes openly.
  2. Reframing mistakes as opportunities for learning and growth to reduce risk aversion and advance innovation.
  3. Creating environments where team members feel safe contributing their unique insights.
  4. Letting creativity and criticism flourish by making candor part of your workplace culture.
  5. Demonstrating trust by ensuring people don't feel silenced or afraid to speak up.

A non-profit organization I worked with was struggling with trust and communication issues stemming from previous dysfunctional leadership. The new executive director was determined to help staff move past the trauma and betrayal to create a culture where people weren't so distrustful, would help and support each other, and felt comfortable communicating and having hard conversations.

Through our Collective Learning work, the executive director created structured opportunities for team members to share concerns in safe settings. She also instituted regular check-ins focused on relationship-building rather than task completion. Perhaps most importantly, she responded to critical feedback with genuine appreciation rather than defensiveness, creating an environment where continuous learning and grace could flourish.

After 12 months of consistent effort, a before-and-after psychological safety survey showed that trust, communication, and engagement had risen by almost 86%. Team members began openly discussing challenges instead of hiding them and supporting each other through difficulties. The organization transformed from a place of guardedness and suspicion to one of trust, grace, and support.

Blind Spot #3: Failing to Empower Solution Seekers

While Blind Spot #1 focuses on the leader's self-perception, this blind spot addresses the leader's operational approach to team empowerment. Leaders often default to providing answers rather than building systems and processes that enable team autonomy. This blind spot prevents an Empowered Ecosystem from flourishing and creates bottlenecks that limit organizational growth.

Signs this blind spot is affecting your team:

  • Team members routinely bring problems to you without potential solutions.
  • Decision-making processes require your approval at multiple stages.
  • You frequently hear "Can I have permission to..." rather than "I'm planning to..."
  • Innovation initiatives stall when you're unavailable.
  • Team members demonstrate capability but lack the confidence to act independently.

The solution: Create systemic team autonomy by building an Empowered Ecosystem

The Empowered Ecosystem pillar of People-Forward Leadership™ reminds us that the perfect solution to a problem is not the one you present but the one your people create. This requires establishing structures and processes that enable independence:

  1. Create clear decision-making frameworks that specify exactly where team members have full autonomy.
  2. Establish problem-solving protocols that team members follow before escalating issues.
  3. Design accountability systems that focus on outcomes rather than methods.
  4. Implement regular practice opportunities for team members to exercise judgment in low-risk scenarios.
  5. Manage your reactive thoughts, such as "It's easier if I do it" or "I don't have time to explain," recognizing these as barriers to ecosystem development.

As Norton Jester wisely noted, "It's not just learning that's important. It's learning what to do with what you learn and why you learn things that matter." This understanding is at the core of creating an Empowered Ecosystem in which team members develop genuine ownership and accountability.

When I headed a graduate program and oversaw a team of admission advisors, faculty, and staff, I personally encountered this blind spot. I believed I was being helpful by staying heavily involved in my team's day-to-day activities. I would frequently check in, provide detailed instructions, and often jump in to ensure work was done to my standards.

Everything changed when one of my team members found the courage to speak up. During a particularly hands-on moment, she looked at me and thoughtfully said, "How am I going to learn if you keep telling me what to do?" While I was grateful that I had created a space where my people felt safe being honest with me, her words hit me like a ton of bricks.

I realized I wasn't trusting in their abilities or giving them room to do their best work their way—not my way. The problem wasn't their capability but my failure to establish systems and processes that would allow them independence while ensuring accountability.

This insight led me to create clearer role definitions, develop standardized processes that team members could follow independently, and establish regular check-in structures that focused on outcomes rather than methods. I forced myself to step back, even when it was uncomfortable, and trust in the framework rather than my direct oversight.

The results transformed both my team and my work. Because I was able to let go of micromanaging their jobs, I was freed up to develop a new subspecialty within the graduate program. This created a new source of revenue and another layer of meaningful work for the team. More importantly, team members flourished with their newfound autonomy, bringing innovations to their roles I wouldn't have imagined.

This experience taught me firsthand that creating a truly Empowered Ecosystem isn't just about believing in your team's potential—it's about deliberately designing operational structures that enable independence while ensuring alignment with organizational goals.

Moving Forward: Integrating the Three Pillars to Overcome Blind Spots

These blind spots persist because they're difficult to see from within. The integrated nature of People-Forward Leadership™ provides the solution. When Leader Awareness, Empowered Ecosystem, and Collective Learning work in concert:

  • Leaders transform from experts to catalysts, accelerating team growth and innovation (Leader Awareness).
  • Teams develop the psychological safety required for collective learning and growth (Collective Learning).
  • Organizations create empowered ecosystems where solution-seeking becomes the norm at every level (Empowered Ecosystem).

By addressing these three critical blind spots through the People-Forward Leadership™ framework, leaders can dismantle outdated, top-down workplace norms and replace them with inclusive, forward-thinking cultures. The result isn't just better performance; it's more sustainable, meaningful, and fulfilling work for everyone involved.

When leaders commit to awareness, empowerment, and learning, these common blind spots become catalysts for transformation rather than barriers to success.

 

 

 

 

Unlock the #1 Issue Plaguing Today's Leaders

Get Time Savvy for Busy Leaders Today!

Time is the scarcest resource leaders have, and how it's allocated matters significantly. As a leader, mastering time management is crucial - it's essential for being present for your team, prioritizing work effectively, and driving your organization forward.

Time Savvy & Training for Busy Leaders

Sign up with your email address to receive news & updates about coaching, leadership development, and strategic advising!

We hate SPAM. We will never sell your information, for any reason.